
Screening and debris removal are two of the most important parts of wastewater filtration, which is why it’s important to ensure that the devices you are using for it are efficient. Trash rakes, in particular, help with maintaining efficiency and preventing system downtime, but like most things, there are a few options for what kind of trash rake to use. We are going to go over our Hydronic T Series and Catronic Series solutions so that you can get a better idea of what might be the best option for you. Every plant has different goals and needs, so knowing what each of these solutions will give you and how they will help you achieve your goals.
What You Need to Know About Trash Rake Systems
First, we are going to go over what exactly a trash rake system is. A trash rake system is an automated or mechanical system that cleans up debris from bar screens in water intake points. They ultimately help with protecting downstream equipment like pumps and can keep your wastewater system running efficiently. Typically, a rake will go into the bar screen and then be pulled across the screen, collecting trapped debris. Once the rake is off the screen, it will dump off the debris into a hopper, dumpster, or truck to dispose of it. One of the main benefits of a trash rake is the automation aspect, as they will automatically be triggered with a calendar, timer, or differential in water pressure to become active, eliminating the need to manually do the raking. It’s essential to have the right model to remove specific debris, as it will affect the efficiency and cost-effectiveness of the plant.
All About the Hydronic T Series Trash Rake
When we look at the Hydronic T Series trash rake, there are some key aspects to consider if you are looking into choosing this option or wanting to see the difference between this one and other options. The first thing to consider is that it is hydronically operated with a telescoping boom design and it’s easily capable of deep channel applications. It can handle pretty heavy debris loads and is suitable for deep or wide intake structures. Another benefit to the performance of these options is that it has a robust and low-maintenance hydronic system, which is how it operates. Ultimately, it is a great option for power plants, large municipal plants, and industrial facilities.
Benefits of a Hydronic T Series:
There are benefits that we want to highlight when it comes to the Hydronic T Series trash rake option. Consider these benefits as they relate to your plant and specific goals or needs within it.
It has high efficiency for cleaning due to the hydronic drive that allows for adjustable pressure on the screen, which leads to optimization of the cleaning
High debris capacity allows it to remove a large amount of trash without needing intervention or a clean out
It’s a great option for deep channels or harsh environments
High-demand operations will benefit from the durability of this option
It requires little maintenance as most of it is automated, and all of the components are located above the water, making any maintenance needed extremely accessible
Negatives of Hydronic T Series Trash Rake:
There are a few drawbacks that we should mention when it comes to opting for a Hydronic T Series and we’re going to go over them so you can make the best decision on what might be best for your needs.
The higher initial cost might not be doable for some facilities as hydronic options are often more expensive
There are higher operating costs when it comes to energy consumption and the need for hydronic fluids to keep it running
There is a possibility of leakage when it comes to the pressurized hydronic lines and seals
It can also be prone to clogging if the bar spacing is too narrow for the type of debris being cleaned, which makes it essential to ensure that this is looked into if you are considering this solution
All About Catronic Series Trash Rake
Now let’s take a look at the Catronic Series trash rake and what it entails, so you have a good understanding of both options here. This trash rake is electrically driven with a cable and carriage system. It also has a compact design which makes it ideal for lighter and more moderate debris loads. When it comes to performance, it has flexible operation with customizable raking depths as well as the benefit of a simple installation and minimal carbon footprint. This is ultimately a better option for smaller plants and facilities that are working with limited space.
Benefits of Catronic Series Trash Rake:
Now we are going to take a look at some of the benefits of a Catronic Series trash rake so you can get a good idea of what the advantages are to choosing this solution over others.
The energy efficiency of this trash rake is immaculate in comparison to other options when it comes to their electric operation
They need low maintenance, and they have easy access for servicing if they do need maintenance
This is a cost-effective option for lighter-duty operations and plants that have smaller debris to clean up
They can be used in a variety of existing structures without needing to completely change it up in order to install
Negatives of a Catronic Series Trash Rake:
If we look at the benefits, then we need to recognize some of the negatives as well to help you make the best decision for your plant. Here are some of the negatives that could come with getting a Catronic Series Trash Rake in comparison to others.
Low water flow can cause air bubbles to form, which can damage turbine blades
It has technology dependence, which means that a shutdown or power outage could stop the system from working
Accumulation of fats, oils, and grease could cause issues of buildup on the rake bars
The channel depth of this option is shallow to moderate
Hydronic T Series vs Catronic Series
Drive Type
hydronic T Series: hydronic
Catronic Series: Electric
Channel Depth
hydronic T Series: Deep
Catronic Series: Shallow to Moderate
Debris Load
hydronic T Series: Heavy
Catronic Series: Light to Medium
Maintenance
hydronic T Series: Low, hydronic-based
Catronic Series: Low, electric-based
Installation
hydronic T Series: Complex and suited for large structures
Catronic Series: Simple and compact setup
Ideal For
hydronic T Series: Power plants and industrial applications
Catronic Series: Municipal plants and compact facilities
Choosing Lakeside Equipment for Your Trash Rake Solution
Now that we’ve gone through the pros, cons, and differences between the hydronic T series and catronic series trash rake options, it’s time to choose one that best fits your needs. Ultimately, it is going to come down to your goals, the type of debris, the size of your facility, and ultimately what you are willing to spend and do when it comes to pricing and maintenance. Regardless of what option you choose, we can help you set up your trash rake with our Lakeside Equipment solutions. If you feel that you know the best option for your facility, contact us, and we’d be happy to get you set up with one of our hydronic T series or electronic series trash rakes.
 









 
        
       